MUST-a-Lab: Migrants' participation in local policymaking

How can migrants participate meaningfully in the development of local integration policies? The European MUST-a-Lab project investigated how multi-stakeholder Policy Labs can involve migrants, policymakers and other stakeholders in developing more inclusive local policies.

Output:

  • Research report
  • Guidelines (English)
  • Guidelines (Dutch)

Contact

siska.vandaele@kdg.be 
+32 3 613 13 62

  • Research centre: Pedagogy in Practice

  • Funding: European Union, Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund (AMIF)
  • Project period: 2021-2024

About the project

MUST-a-Lab (2021–2024) developed and implemented Policy Labs in six European cities: Mechelen, Modena, Fuenlabrada, Grenoble Alpes Métropole, Livadia and Vienna. Each city addressed specific challenges related to migration and integration, involving migrants, local authorities, professionals and civil society organisations.

The methodology builds on participatory and deliberative democracy, particularly mini-publics: small groups in which participants engage in facilitated dialogue, examine policy challenges, develop proposals and formulate recommendations.

MUST-a-Lab examined how the Policy Labs method can strengthen migrants' participation in policymaking, while addressing inequalities related to communicative opportunities and institutional power.

Our research contribution

KdG's Research Centre Pedagogy in Practice, in collaboration with the University of Modena and Reggio Emilia (UNIMORE), conducted the evaluation research across the six Policy Labs.

The research aligned with the centre's expertise in participation, inclusion and evaluation and practice-oriented research, particularly concerning children and young people. It examined how migrants and other underrepresented groups can contribute to deliberative processes and influence policy development.

The evaluation combined interviews, focus groups, questionnaires, video analysis and document analysis. It investigated the organisation and facilitation of the Policy Labs, participants' opportunities to contribute to discussions and decisions, and the follow-up of policy recommendations. Particular attention was paid to children and young people with a migration background. In Mechelen, the Policy Lab addressed pupils' sense of belonging at school. The research examined the conditions supporting children's participation alongside adults, as well as the risks of unequal participation and marginalisation.

Partners

MUST-a-Lab involved six European local authorities and four supporting partners: KdG, UNIMORE, the International Institute of Humanitarian Law (IIHL) and the Forum des Régions Européennes pour la Recherche, l'Éducation et la Formation (FREREF).

Results and publications

Our research centre was responsible for the following publications:

(1) Report on semi-structured interviews and focus groups

This report presents qualitative research into participants' experiences of the Policy Labs, examining opportunities for participation, collaboration and the challenges of involving migrants and other stakeholders in local policymaking.

Download the research report here.

(2) Co-creating Solutions: a guide to inclusive Policy Labs about migration and integration, based on the MUST-a-Lab project

Drawing on the experiences and evaluation of the six Policy Labs, these guidelines combine the theoretical foundations of deliberative democracy with practical guidance on designing, organising and facilitating inclusive Policy Labs.

They address participant recruitment, dialogue and facilitation, experimentation and the follow-up of policy recommendations. Developed in the context of migration and integration, the methodology can also be applied to other policy areas.

  • Download the guidelines (ENG)
  • Download the guidelines (NL)

(3)  Forthcoming book

The evaluation research also forms the basis of a forthcoming scientific book with Palgrave Macmillan.

Drawing on a mixed-methods analysis of the six European Policy Labs, the book examines Policy Labs as a specific form of deliberative mini-publics. It analyses migrants' opportunities to exercise agency, the role of facilitation, inequalities in participation and the translation of participants' recommendations into local integration policies. Particular attention is paid to the participation of migrant children and young people.

Authors Claudio Baraldi (UNIMORE), Antonella Capalbi (formerly UNIMORE), Sophie Mols (KdG) and Siska van Daele (KdG).

Visit the MUST-a-Lab website

Want to know more, collaborate or have a press question?

You can work with the research centre Pedagogy in Practice on various topics, including:

  • Connecting different pedagogical practices.
  • Expertise on organisational structures.
  • Practical tools that focus on interactions in pedagogical practices.

Contact us without obligation